For the full off season thus far, each of the oxygen in the area enclosing the grabbing market was squeezed up from the endless J.T. Realmuto exchange play. That is not hard to understand, because Realmuto is very fine, and also at a downward cycle to get catchers, he’s most likely the finest allaround backstop in baseball. Based on reports, he will likely be traded this off season.

The problem is, nothing’s happened, because Miami’s requirements are apparently excessive. The Mets got completely fed up and proceeded on into Wilson Ramos, other teams could possibly do the same, which seems like a great time for you to remind you: Hey, remember Yasmani Grandal? He’s available, he’s just about as great as Realmuto, and he’d cost just money (and a redesign pick), not prospects.  

That requires repeating is clearly due in no small part to Grandal himself, because he had been unavoidably lousy in October, hitting just .138/.265/.276 and getting benched thanks to some highprofile defensive miscues. It was a terrible look on the biggest period, and it has probably using the reverse free agent effect compared to that of Joe Kelly, that probably shook a fantastic postseason to an third guaranteed season on the free agent sector.

Nevertheless , we should be aware enough by now to know that postseason performance doesn’t do to predict future performance. No one’s ever going to whine that David Price“doesn’t understand just how to win in October,” with no one really gave National League Most Valuable Player Christian Yelich a tricky time for hitting .194/.383/.389 around two playoff series that October. 

If you’re able to get beyond those bad few weeks, then you can see just how valuable Grandal is — and how many teams may desperately use him. It breaks down.

Video: [email protected] Gm2: Grandal straps a solo home run to directly

Grandal was as good or even better than Realmuto at 2018

Look at these two batting lines, wont you?

All these are two lines that are simply about as identical because they can get, to the point that it almost doesn’t matter that line belongs to that player. (Realmuto was the initial person, Grandal the second) While neither steals bases (three to Grandal, two to get Realmuto), high level base running metrics believe the slow-footed Grandal a drawback on the foundations (minus-six runs) whereas the comparatively rapid Realmuto adds value (plus-5 runs). It’s enough to offer Realmuto the edge .

However, the gap, naturally, comes behind the plate. Realmuto is a perfectly solid back stop, a person who owns the speediest pop moment in baseball (1.90 moments ). While that is fine, it’s matter just how valuable that actually is, since stolen base attempts keep dropping and dropping in baseball. While you’d be prepared you’ll discover Grandal had a much worse time preventing chunks from getting by him, that’s not accurate; he had 40 passed balls/wild pitches in 2018, while Realmuto, at 86 fewer innings, had 42.

G: 40.1%Barrel%G: 11.9percent

We will pitch framing here, obviously, and that’s a location in which there is a massive gap. Over at Baseball Prospectus, they keep track of such things, and the results couldn’t be more better. Grandal has been the ideal pitch-framer in baseball, adding plus-16 runs of significance. Realmuto, however, was essentially league-average, neither very good nor poor.

This is definitely an art and craft of Grandal, who’s ranked at or near the top of these lists every year. Here’s exactly that which Greinke said to this Los Angeles Times roughly Grandal, that caught every Greinke start during that stretch.

“He has been unbelievable back there,” Greinke said. “His catching is better than advertised, and dealing with me individually, he has been as good as you can expect. I really don’t believe, from what I have seen thus far, you can ever have expected anything more”

“I couldn’t set a far much better catcher right now.”

That is high praise. It feels like people sometimes have a tough time understanding the value of pitch , which is because it’s tough to see it. That is, when a catcher enables a pitch go to the back stop or even airmails a throw, then it’s pretty simple to notice. When he moves the ball four an inch to transform it into a strike three, it’s much more difficult to determine.

It’s much more valuable, nevertheless. It’s why the range of framing runs moves not quite 35 runs in the top to bottom, Grandal’s +16 into Willson Contreras’ minus-18, as the variety of obstructing is only about 10 runs in the top to bottom, and the worth of throwing less than that.

Not every edition of Wins Above Replacement includes that value. one that does has Grandal beneath the catcher list, at 5 wins. Second is Realmuto, at 4.3. They truly are the only real ones above 3.5. There exists a powerful argument why these are both best catchers in baseball. Grandal’s poor October hurts that, but it doesn’t undo it.

Video: [email protected]: Grandal rescues Dodgers with 2-homer match

It’s perfectly reasonable to prefer Realmuto’s childhood, his consistency, his salary is leaner and that he won’t cost a Draft pick, and that he didn’t just have that highprofile October explosion. That all matters. On the flip side, Grandal wont require parting with Kyle Tucker or even Brandon Nimmo or even Cody Bellinger — most of names which come up in Realmuto rumors — and the real take away here is that for teams that are reluctant or not able to meet the Marlins, Grandal is more of a 1A than an idea B. Not every team gets those kinds of prospects. All of them have dollars.

Ok, so… who should that be? 

The teams that will desperately use him

Taking a look at the current free agent catcher list, the rest of the pickings are still slim. You need to exchange for Realmuto, or you want to sign Grandal.

You could argue for a whole great deal of teams , such as the Phillies, Astros, Brewers or perhaps a’s. We are going to argue for these three. 


Here’s the thickness chart, but don’t cheat. Give up?

The two Angels catchers right now are Jose Briceno, that hit .239/.299/.385 for a rookie in 2018, and Kevan Smith, that had been claimed off waivers from the White Sox last month. Need less to say, that is not adequate enough, plus it’s really why the Angels backstops position as the fifth-weakest from the game, per FanGraphs projections.

There is absolutely no better way to keep on doing that than by simply adding an elite framer, person that might help make the inconsistent Angels throwing seem much better.

Video: Bollinger discusses Angels’ improvements to turning


Much of the same could be said about the Rockies, that currently have the same trio (Chris Iannetta, Tom Murphy and Tony Wolters) who combined to hit most of .207/.314/.354 at 2018. This has been part of why the 2018 Rockies had such issues on crime, and they made their first move to mend that at 20-19 by enrolling Daniel Murphy

That is a nice start, but Murphy alone wont mend their problems. If they are really going to start Ryan McMahon at 2nd base and proceed with Ian Desmond among their three outfield starters (along side Charlie Blackmon and David Dahl), then this could be the main spot for Colorado to upgrade. Grandal would be a huge add behind the plate, but next to it, too. 


We know there is more to catching than hitting, particularly in the present framing-heavy highvelocity game. In addition, we know that the Red Sox won 108 games and a World Series with the catching group they’d. And it’s our duty to tell you the 313 hitters took at 250 plate looks in 2018, and the base three look like this:


That is generally not what you desire. It’s likely the Red Sox simply go roll with this particular pair (and Blake Swihart again), so they decide to focus their spending Craig Kimbrel or someone like him. But there’s room for improvement . Tons of it.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here